The Squirt Bottle Controversy

Listen to the audio version of this article

It looks innocent enough. It’s a little plastic squirt bottle sitting on the kitchen counter. In that plastic bottle is plain tap water. That little plastic bottle, as innocent as it looks, has become the tool that is destroying the bond you share with your cat. The reason? You’re using the squirt bottle to deter your cat from engaging in any number of behaviors you deem inappropriate or unwanted. squirt!

It’s an Ineffective Tool

The squirt bottle deterrent, in many cat households, has become the popular method for keeping cats off counters and tables. It is also the way many people attempt to stop their cats from scratching the furniture. The squirt bottle is used to stop a cat who is getting too aggressive, either with another companion animal or with a human family member. The squirt bottle has become the tool many cat parents reach for immediately when kitty isn’t acting the way we want him to act.

Think Like a Cat by Pam Johnson-Bennett

You’d think that based on the popularity of the squirt bottle technique, it must be an extremely effective and successful method of training cats. The truth is though, it’s not effective at training a cat to cease engaging in unwanted behaviors. The squirt bottle technique only accomplishes three things:

  1. It creates frustration in the cat
  2. It causes the cat to become afraid of you
  3. The cat learns to wait until you aren’t around before engaging in the behavior

Punishment Doesn’t Work

When you punish a cat for exhibiting a behavior you don’t like, it doesn’t stop the behavior. First, it’s important to understand that regardless of how unwanted the behavior is, it serves a purpose for the cat. Your cat isn’t scratching on the sofa or jumping on the counter just to make you mad. Animals engage in behaviors that serve a function (i.e. a pay-off). Additionally, many of the behaviors cat parents view as unwanted, such as furniture scratching, are normal, natural behaviors. When you squirt the cat with water for scratching the furniture you may momentarily stop the behavior but the cat has a normal and natural need to scratch. If he gets punished every time he attempts to engage in a normal behavior, he will probably become afraid of you and he’ll also continue the behavior in secret. That’s a very stressful combination.alert cat

So instead of trying to train a cat by punishing him for engaging in normal behaviors, here’s a better idea…

Think Like a Cat

Figure out why the cat exhibits a particular behavior so you can provide a better option. If your cat is scratching the furniture then it probably means you either don’t have a scratching post or it’s the wrong kind. If your cat is getting aggressive with another companion animal, then it’s time to do some behavior modification work to help them develop a positive association with each other. Squirting the cat with water when he’s reacting to another cat will do nothing to help them ever form a peaceful relationship.

When training your cat, one of the most important tools is trust. Your cat needs to be able to trust you in order to form that important bond. The last thing you want is for your cat to run from you out of fear. So it’s time to put that squirt bottle away and use a more humane and productive training method. Think like a cat and look at your environment from your cat’s point of view and you’ll be surprised at how much more effective your training techniques will become.

Need More Information?

For more specifics on effective, humane training techniques, refer to any of Pam’s books, including Think Like a Cat.

Think Like a Cat by Pam Johnson-Bennett



Due to Pam’s scheduling demands, we’re sorry but she is unable to respond to questions or remarks posted in the comment section. If you have a question about cat behavior, you can find many answers in the articles Pam writes for the website as well as in her best-selling books.



About Pam Johnson-Bennett

Pam Johnson-Bennett is the host of Animal Planet UK's PSYCHO KITTY, She is a best-selling author of nine books, including Think Like a Cat: how to raise a well-adjusted cat – not a sour puss. For over 25 years, her books have been called cat bibles by veterinarians, behavior experts, shelters and cat parents worldwide. Pam is considered a pioneer in the field of cat behavior consulting. Pam owns Cat Behavior Associates, a private veterinarian-referred behavior company in Nashville, TN.

Check Also

Halloween infographic

Halloween Cat Safety Infographic

CanWest Veterinary Conference

Pam to Speak at the 2015 CanWest Veterinary Conference

Pam Johnson-Bennett, host of Animal Planet UK’s PSYCHO KITTY and best-selling cat behavior author will be speaking at the 2015 CanWest Veterinary Conference. Hosted by the Alberta Veterinary Medical Association, the CanWest conference will be held ...

Pam Johnson-Bennett to speak for Pet Matters Summer Series

Pam to Speak at 2015 Pet Matters Seminar

Come join the host of the Animal Planet UK series Psycho Kitty, for a free one-hour seminar on cat behavior. Once again, Pam will be speaking at the beautiful Farm at Natchez Trace in Franklin, Tennessee. ...

kitten outside

How to Safely Remove a Tick

You certainly don’t want to find a tick on your cat, your dog or yourself, but if you do, here’s information from the Centers for Disease Control on how to remove it safely. You need javascript ...

We're updating the store and apologize for the time being, but it will be back once our changes are completed.